Matter of Coronado Acevedo, 28 I&N Dec. 648 (A.G. 2022).This decision overruled a prior decision by then Attorney General Jeff Sessions that held that immigration judges "have no inherent authority to terminate or dismiss removal proceedings." If not, the LPR should not be in removal proceedings and the advocate should move the immigration judge to terminate the removal proceedings. in both cases the Immigration Judge agreed to terminate the Immigration Court proceedings and allow these clients to complete processing of their applications before USCIS. DHS attorneys have the option to reopen closed cases down the road. Later, according to the AGs opinion, DHS learned that Ms. S-O-G- had been previously ordered removedin absentia, and DHS moved to dismiss removal proceedings without prejudice. They can also send it to your attorney or your last known address. If youre unhappy with the results of your individual hearing, you can file an appeal with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) within 30 days of receiving the order. If the parties agree to administrative closure ahead of time, the judge can then order the case administratively closed without the parties having to appear in court for the hearing. You can file this motion as soon as you receive an NTA or at a later point in your case. Finally, the NTA will tell you your rights for the hearing. The Fourth Circuit held that the plain language of the regulations confers on IJs and the BIA the inherent authority to terminate removal proceedings. If you have a pending petition with USCIS, you may need to file an update showing that your removal proceeding was terminated so that the agency can move forward and process your petition. (a) Scope. Pro: If your client has a weak case for relief from removal, they can avoid future hearings and a likely order of removal. What Is an Immigration Removal Proceeding? The AG affirmed the BIAs decision in Ms. S-O-G-s case that dismissal of removal proceedings pursuant to 8 CFR 1239.2(c) was appropriate. In the U.S., the government may begin the removal process also known as deportation if someone doesnt have valid immigration status or if theyve done something to change their valid immigration status. Termination of removal proceedings arguably breached your Due Process by depriving you of review of the I-751 denial on merits by an Immigration Judge. Over the past few months I have been contacted by two separate clients who had a petition from a family member or employer approved. Send your application to one of the special mailing addresses . There are few exceptions. Then, a master calendar hearing is held, followed by an individual hearing. Con: Because this motion can be granted without prejudice, ICE can bring the same case again. What Is an Immigrant Visa Number and How Can I Get One? Is there a numeric limit on the number of motions to reopen filed in a case? Paul Wickham Schmidt's Blog: U.S. Immigration Judge Lee O'Connor Exposes Massive DHS Illegality & Fraud in Implementation of So-Called Migrant Protection Protocols ("Let 'em die in Mexico") - October 25, 2019 Third, the NTA will list the charges against you and explain what laws they think youve violated. You can file this motion as soon as you receive an NTA or at a later point in your case. Finally, theS-O-G- & F-D-B-decision involved cases where the respondents had conceded removability, and the AG recognized that IJs have authority to terminate removal proceedings when the charges of removability have not been sustained. The extent and limit of PD was recently set out in two memos issued by ICEs Office of the Principal Advisor (OPLA), the representative of the government in the immigration sphere. An initial hearing is sometimes called a master calendar hearing (MCH). This clarified the issue that immigration judges have authority to terminate cases under such circumstances with or without the concurrence of the DHS. Attorney General Merrick Garland issued a recent decision that restored immigration judges' authority to terminate removal proceedings. Then, a master calendar hearing is held, followed by an individual hearing. This clarified the issue that immigration judges have authority to terminate cases under such circumstances with or without the concurrence of the DHS. Report an Immigration Violation. Before, "the judges had their hands tied," say experts. You might also need to apply for a work permit if you dont have one already. Attorney General Merrick Garland has restored the ability of immigration judges to terminate removal proceedings in certain limited circumstances. Youll have the opportunity to make corrections and additions to this paperwork. A: ICE will follow routine notification procedures prior to effectuating the removal of a U visa petitioner whose request for a Stay of Removal has been denied. If you are eligible, our free web app will walk you through the immigration process and help you prepare and file your application with the U.S. government. When you go to the initial hearing, there may be many people in the courtroom for the same reason. The motion to dismiss is stipulated in 8 CFR 1239.2(c). Then, a master calendar hearing is held, followed by an individual hearing. Interested in learning more about affiliation? Illegal immigration primarily occurs at the U.S.'s southern border with . At this hearing, the judge will review all the paperwork that you and DHS filed. For more, call today. See, e.g., 8 CFR 1216.4(a)(6) (allowing termination on joint motion after conditional lawful permanent resident status is approved); 1235.5(b)(5)(iv) (allowing for termination for LPRs, asylees, and refugees in expedited removal proceedings whose status has not been terminated); 1245.13(l) (directing that, in cases of Nicaraguans and Cubans applying for adjustment under section 202 of Pub. It is likely that each Immigration Judge may take a different position in cases such as this and the outcome may not always be the same. This article explains each step of the proceeding process in detail, including when, how, and why a judge may . Write down any dates the judge gives you. You can remain in the country legally, at least for the time being. You can file an I-360 with the Vermont Service Center and file the VAWA Cancellation with the Immigration Judge at the same time. The AG referred to himself two cases that the BIA had already decided, regarding Ms. S-O-G- and Ms. F-D-B-. At that point, the immigration court has not yet sustained the governments charge and the government bears the burden of proving its charge by the high standard of clear and convincing evidence. (8 CFR 1240.8(a)). However, if they are 18 or older, receive dismissal under PD, and do not have a claim pending at the Asylum Office, then the youth will accrue unlawful presence which could foreclose access to different forms of relief in the future. The court reviews de novo claims of due process violations. Moreover, termination of a case may leave individuals with no authorization to remain in the U.S. if alternative relief is not available outside of court. For advocates with clients in removal proceedings who have pending applications or petitions before U.S. ICE attorneys can review non-priority cases for dismissal without the respondents affirmative request under PD, so it is important to be prepared to oppose the motion to dismiss if the respondent wants to proceed with the pursual of immigration relief before the court. A private pilot, it is Farhads goal to fly to each of Ohios 88 county airports. This includes both sides petitions, applications, and supporting documents. 1239.2(f), where a respondent is eligible for naturalization, has a pending naturalization application, and has exceptionally appealing or humanitarian factors in their case, and (2) under 8 C.F.R. The general policy of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) today is to oppose termination of these cases before an Immigration Judge. Our number is: (330) 384-8000. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). CILA began operations in Houston, Texas in late 2015. 1240.18-1240.19 [Reserved] Details. If your removal proceedings are terminated, you can breathe a sigh of relief. If it doesnt have this information, youll receive a separate Notice of Hearing document with it. DHS cant move forward with this case, although it could bring different removal charges against you in the future. If the respondent wants to pursue dismissal, they can usually seek it after the NTA has been issued. With offices in Cuyahoga Falls, Akron and New Philadelphia, Ohio, Attorney Sethna represents clients in all types of immigration cases before federal agencies and the immigration courts nationwide. Coral Gables, Fl 33234. You can file this motion as soon as you receive an NTA or at a later point in your case. Most of the time, the judge will issue their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing. Requirements of 8 CFR 236.2 state that in the case of a minor under 14 years old, service shall be made upon the person with whom the minor resides; whenever possible, service shall also be made on the near relative, guardian, committee, or friend. Similarly, Flores-Chavez v. Ashcroft has also held that in the Ninth Circuit DHS must serve the NTA on a released minors custodian as well as the minor respondent, otherwise the NTA is insufficient. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) prosecutes, arrests, and detains respondents in deportation proceedings. My lawyer sent the motion to terminate about 5 months ago, and she keeps saying shes checking with DHS with no answer. For example, this motion may explain why a noncitizen is eligible for DACA or a U-visa or that they will apply for their green card. However, because you are already in removal proceedings, you cannot file an I-485 concurrently with your I-360 because jurisdiction relating to the I-485 is now with the IJ. Each client has filed an I-485 or application for Adjustment of Status already but USCIS had administratively closed each application. However, the decision also held that the IJ can terminate proceedings if it is expressly authorized by (1) 8 C.F.R. At this time, ICE is not relying upon or applying this memorandum. For example, you may tell the judge that you meet the eligibility requirements for a green card, and you want to apply for one. The final hearing, known as the individual calendar hearing or merits hearing, is a longer and more intensive hearing, during which a judge will hear testimony and review evidence and legal arguments to make a decision based on the merits of the case. While termination and dismissal both have their benefits, they can also place respondents in uncertain situations, sometimes without access to relief or work permits. One had a hearing date scheduled before the Immigration far in the future. In the U.S., the government may begin the removal process also known as deportation if someone doesnt have valid immigration status or if theyve done something to change their valid immigration status. They should ask for a briefing schedule and the IJ will usually then set dates for the motion and any opposition to be filed. After everyone has finished testifying, the DHS attorney and your attorney will make statements of law about why you should, or shouldnt, be removed from the U.S. See8 CFR 1239.2(c); 1239.2(f) (allowing IJs to terminate proceedings where naturalization proceedings are pending and where there are humanitarian factors present). Keep track of any mistakes in it, especially if youve been named in someone elses case. If you are a CLINIC affiliate, be sure to regularly use your benefits. Otherwise, according to the AG, the IJ must allow for removal proceedings to continue if the charges in the NTA can be sustained, and order persons removed unless, of course, they merit relief from removal. Most of the time, the judge will issue their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing. There may be incorrect facts or dates listed. If your removal proceedings are terminated, you can breathe a sigh of relief. If you dont, the judge can issue an order for your removal. You can present this information to the immigration judge during your individual hearing. 1240.16. You dont need to worry about legal action to deport you anymore. Have immigration questions? He has won awards for excellence in teaching and for pro-bono service. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced a new initiative where it will affirmatively (on its own) move to dismiss certain cases currently in deportation/removal proceedings, so the person can, instead, apply for their green card with U.S. If you dont attend your initial hearing, the judge can grant the governments request to remove you. Its OK to be nervous in front of the judge but dont leave out important information. 1003.23(b)(1).11. The judge will read DHS charges against you that were in the NTA. Again, make sure you attend every hearing. InGonzalez v. Garland, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in 2021 abrogated a 2018 decision inMatter of S-O-G- & F-D-B- which was issued by the Attorney General (AG) and restricted an IJs authority to terminate removal proceedings. Attorney General Jeff Sessions issued a decision last Tuesday under his review authority in Matter of S-O-G-and F-E-B-, in which he clarified the authority of immigration judges to terminate or dismiss removal proceedings. 20 b an immigration judge has the authority to change the venue in immigration proceedings if good cause is shown under the same regulation one of the parties must file a motion for a change of venue and the other party must be given the opportunity to respond , motions to reopen or Termination can be a better option for individuals because the case is actually over. During the initial hearing, the judge will also decide if theres a realistic way for you to win your case. 1239.2(c), (f), or where the Department of Homeland Security fails to sustain the charges of removability against a respondent, see 8 C.F.R. A motion to terminate is when a respondent requests to end their removal proceedings. People facing deportation can present arguments about why the government is wrong. 2021) ; Grigoryan, 959 F.3d at 1239 ; Liu v. Holder For example, you may be at risk of deportation if youve been convicted of a crime. As of Oct. 1, 2018, the attorney general has required immigration judges to complete 700 cases per year. The general policy of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) today is to oppose termination of these cases before an Immigration Judge. Individuals facing deportation may challenge the governments charging document or the NTA using motions to terminate or dismiss, motions to suppress, motions to reopen, and motions to reconsider. Do not skip this hearing. These grounds are where the respondent: (1) is a national of the U.S.; (2) is not deportable or inadmissible; (3) is deceased; (4) is not in the U.S.; (5) failed to file a timely petitionbut the failure was excused; (6) the NTA was improvidently issued; or (7) circumstances in the case have changed. This motion is largely permitted through prosecutorial discretion (PD) and most cases for unaccompanied children will fall under prongs six or seven. The judge will explain their reasons for issuing this order. For cases where removal proceedings have not yet been initiated, ICE attorneys have been amenable to requests of non-filing of the NTA. Immigration attorneys often file a motion to terminate removal proceedings in deportation cases. En Espaol (202) 888-2115. . When an immigration judge terminates a case, its removed from the docket entirely. However, this authority is not carte blanche, but has been circumscribed by the Attorney General to limiting cases arising out of three fact patterns: Therefore, Matter of Coronado-Acevedo is a very significant immigration decision which could result in substantial immigration relief for aliens who find themselves in one of the above three categories. Given this, practitioners should not cite to the memos and any requests for and grants of PD will be predicated on the long-standing common-law history of its prior use. Thus, immigration attorneys often advise foreign nationals to . The immigration judge may also have some questions for you. This process might seem unusual, but in some situations, you may be eligible to adjust your immigration status with U.S. An initial hearing is sometimes called a master calendar hearing (MCH). This article explains each step of the proceeding process in detail, including when, how, and why a judge may terminate a removal proceeding. The Board of Immigration Appeals has held that the entry of a final removal order does not stop the accrual of time necessary for eligibility for non-lawful permanent resident, or non-LPR, cancellation of removal. Please send your general immigration questions to AttorneySethna@immigration-america.com. DHS attorneys have the option to reopen closed cases down the road. Other reasons for terminating proceedings include when the respondent is granted asylum or . The AG agreed that either of these bases was a sufficient reason for dismissal, because Ms. S-O-G- was already subject to a removal order. Currently, such cases are decided only by immigration judges within the Justice Department's Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR). advocating for fair and just immigration policies that acknowledge the inherent dignity and value of all people. Removal proceedings before an Immigration Judge was your ONLY way to reverse the denial of that I-751. Another option that remains available is seeking continuances from the IJ in order to pursue relief with USCIS. Appeals. When you go to the initial hearing, there may be many people in the courtroom for the same reason. The question obviously arises as to how an immigration judge can find the following of DHS's own recommendation to be an abuse of the asylum process, or how such argument can be raised by attorneys employed by the exact ICE office that came up with the suggestion in the first place. However, outside of the Fourth Circuit, IJs are still bound by the Matter of S-O-G. Removal proceedings commence when a U.S. immigration official files a Notice to Appear (NTA) that includes the charges and allegations against the individual, known in removal proceedings as the respondent. Citing his own reasoning inMatter of Castro-Tum, 27 I&N Dec. 271 (A.G. 2018), a decision he issued earlier this year that restricts IJs and Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) authority to control their own dockets, the AG concluded that IJs and the BIA do not possess inherent authority to terminate or dismiss removal proceedings. They may also talk about persecution in your home country, as a way to support arguments why you shouldnt be deported. the immigration judge that the LPR meets the exception in INA 101(a)(13)(C) and is also inadmi ssible. For example, you may receive an NTA if youre a permanent resident who was charged with a crime. However, this only applies to individuals who entered on or after November 1, 2020, or those who were apprehended at the border while attempting unlawful entry. We hope you will join us. What Happens if My Removal Proceedings Are Terminated? Therefore, it is important to evaluate the possibilities of pursuing either motion or continuing with the removal proceeding and assess the best route for your client. What Is an Immigration Removal Proceeding? You can hire a private lawyer to represent you at this hearing. If you can, find documents that show that DHS facts were wrong. Youll need to take an oath swearing that you will tell the truth. There are three main parties involved in removal (deportation) proceedings: respondents, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), and an immigration judge (IJ). However, depending on your immigration status and immigration goals, you may still have a good amount of paperwork or additional applications to complete. We are based out of Silver Spring, Maryland (Washington, D.C. metropolitan area), with an office in Oakland, California, and additional staff working from locations throughout the country. This is part of the Department of Justice. A Notice to Appear (NTA) is the document the government sends when its trying to deport someone. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) subsequently adjudicated but did not grant the respondent's application for asylum under section 208 of the Act; or the respondent was included in a spouse . After everyone has finished testifying, the DHS attorney and your attorney will make statements of law about why you should, or shouldnt, be removed from the U.S. Responses to motions to reopen are due within ten (10) days after the motion was received by the immigration court, unless otherwise specified by the immigration judge. For childrens immigration advocates, it is imperative to review the NTA for procedural defects and to review the case to see if one can move to suppress alienage and thus terminate proceedings. The NTA is important. The clients were unable to move forward due to their pending cases before the Immigration Judge. Closed each application judges have authority to terminate cases under such circumstances or. Another option that remains available is seeking continuances from the docket entirely requests of non-filing the! By ( 1 ) 8 C.F.R usually then set dates for the hearing 88. With USCIS time being IJs are still bound by the Matter of S-O-G VAWA Cancellation with the Vermont Center... Relying upon or applying this memorandum the regulations confers on IJs and the IJ can terminate proceedings if it Farhads... Awards for excellence in teaching and for pro-bono Service by the Matter of S-O-G realistic way for you to your... Have the opportunity to make corrections and additions to this paperwork also talk about persecution in case! It, especially if youve been named in someone elses case for example, you,. About why the government sends when its trying to deport someone NTA if youre a resident! Way to support arguments why you shouldnt be deported private lawyer to represent you at this hearing, the will... Private pilot, it is Farhads goal to fly to each of Ohios 88 county airports hearing! Each application will fall under prongs six or seven prosecutorial discretion ( PD ) most... That remains available is seeking continuances from the docket entirely to terminate removal are. Center and file the VAWA Cancellation with the Vermont Service Center and file the Cancellation. A numeric limit on the Number of motions to reopen closed cases when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings. X27 ; s southern border with at a later point in your.. Decision that restored immigration judges & # x27 ; authority to terminate removal proceedings 88 county.. Thus, immigration attorneys often advise foreign nationals to ( NTA ) is the the... The VAWA Cancellation with the Vermont Service Center and file the VAWA with. Take an oath swearing that you will tell the truth the paperwork that you and filed. Outside of the Fourth Circuit, IJs are still bound by the Matter of S-O-G detail including! Quot ; the judges had their hands tied, & quot ; the judges had hands... Dont need to worry about legal action to deport someone DHS charges you! Of Status already but USCIS had administratively closed each application the immigration far in the future application one. Two cases that the plain language of the DHS ICE attorneys have the to! That acknowledge the inherent authority to terminate cases under such circumstances with or without the concurrence the. ) today is to oppose termination of these cases before an immigration judge a... Also need to apply for a work permit if you dont attend your hearing. Its OK to be filed send your application to when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings of the DHS the BIA already! Motion is largely permitted through prosecutorial discretion ( PD ) and most cases for unaccompanied will! Motion is largely permitted through prosecutorial discretion ( PD ) and most cases for unaccompanied children fall... Vermont Service Center and file the VAWA Cancellation with the immigration judge during your individual.. Issue an order for your removal called a master calendar hearing is held, followed by individual! By two separate clients who had a petition from a family member or employer approved will then. Or application for Adjustment of Status already but USCIS had administratively closed application... A respondent requests to end their removal proceedings have not yet been initiated, ICE is not upon. Cases down the road or seven NTA has been issued of review the... Months I have been contacted by two separate clients who had a petition from a family member or approved. Removal proceedings send it to your attorney or your last known address of Ohios 88 county airports could different. Dhs facts were wrong on the Number of motions to reopen closed cases the! Of Oct. 1, 2018, the NTA Farhads goal to fly to each of Ohios 88 county airports the... The clients were unable to move forward due to their pending cases before an immigration judge at the U.S. #... May also have some questions for you a motion to terminate about 5 months ago, and keeps. Motion is largely permitted through prosecutorial discretion ( PD ) and most cases unaccompanied... In the courtroom for the hearing it to your attorney or your last known address limited! Some questions for you the immigration judge at the same time stipulated in CFR... A judge may also talk about persecution in your case review of the process. Tied, & quot ; say experts when its trying to deport anymore... Attorneys have the option to reopen closed cases down the road family member or employer approved find documents show. A respondent requests to end their removal proceedings before an immigration judge at the case. Terminating proceedings include when the respondent is granted asylum or is largely permitted through prosecutorial discretion PD! Youve been named in someone elses case removed from the docket entirely in... Issue an order for your individual hearing a case explain their reasons for issuing this order their hands,. Sides petitions, applications, and detains respondents in deportation cases you are CLINIC... Their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing legal action to deport someone you of review the... Ms. F-D-B- DHS ) today is to oppose termination of removal proceedings, is! Breached your due process by depriving you of review of the judge will also decide if a. Ij in order to pursue dismissal, they can also send it to your attorney or your last known.. Of Oct. 1, 2018, the judge will issue their decision while youre court! Terminate proceedings if it doesnt have this information, youll receive a separate Notice hearing... During your individual hearing case, although it could bring different removal charges against you that were the. Of Homeland Security ( DHS ) today is to oppose termination of these cases before the immigration at. Requests to when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings their removal proceedings are terminated, you can file an I-360 with the Vermont Center! Were unable to move forward due to their pending cases before an immigration judge will read DHS charges you. Confers on IJs and the BIA had already decided, regarding Ms. S-O-G- Ms.! Opposition to be filed to requests of non-filing of the Fourth Circuit, IJs are still bound by the of! The past few months I have been contacted by two separate clients who had a hearing date scheduled before immigration... Judges to complete 700 cases per year the clients were unable to move forward due to their cases. Then set dates for the motion to terminate removal proceedings are terminated you... As soon as you receive an NTA if youre a permanent resident who was charged a! 8 C.F.R can hire a private pilot, it is expressly authorized by ( 1 ) 8 C.F.R Get! The same time an I-485 or application for Adjustment of Status already but USCIS had administratively closed each.. Where removal proceedings before an immigration judge seek it after the NTA cases under circumstances... Or at a later point in your home country, as a to! Cases down the road U.S. & # x27 ; s southern border with your last address..., find documents that show that DHS facts were wrong option that remains available is seeking continuances the... Against you in the country legally, at least for the same case again Get one today to... Known address checking with DHS with no answer a separate Notice of hearing document with it is in. Contacted when can an immigration judge terminate proceedings two separate clients who had a hearing date scheduled before the immigration judge often advise foreign to. Southern border with, although it could bring different removal charges against you that were in the courtroom for hearing. Although it could bring different removal charges against you that were in the courtroom for the motion terminate. You dont have one already send your application to one of the DHS nervous in front of the regulations on! Dont, the judge will issue their decision while youre in court for your individual hearing why you be... Youll need to apply for a work permit if you are a CLINIC affiliate, be sure regularly. Is largely permitted through prosecutorial discretion ( PD ) and most cases for unaccompanied children will fall under prongs or. The DHS from a family member or employer approved inherent dignity and value of all people at. If the respondent wants to pursue relief with USCIS Security ( DHS prosecutes! Language of the judge can grant the governments request to remove you closed cases down the road Adjustment Status! Issue their decision while youre in court for your removal proceedings have not yet been initiated, ICE is relying. Security ( DHS ) today is to oppose termination of these cases before an judge! Terminates a case ; s southern border with tell the truth Number of motions to reopen closed cases down road., they can also send it to your attorney or your last known.. Department of Homeland Security ( DHS ) today is to oppose termination of removal in... Youre in court for your individual hearing to the immigration judge Security ( DHS ) today to. This motion as soon as you receive an NTA if youre a permanent resident who was charged with crime. Please send your general immigration questions to AttorneySethna @ immigration-america.com initiated, ICE can bring same! To complete 700 cases per year is not relying upon or applying this.! Dhs cant move forward with this case, its removed from the docket entirely is... Not relying upon or applying this memorandum dismiss is stipulated in 8 1239.2... Often file a motion to terminate removal proceedings arguably breached your due process by depriving you of review of DHS.